This feeling has been complicated by the fact that so many of the awesome aspects of Gargoyle of Gotham are surprises, better experienced in context without a mediator like me excitedly shoving the book in your face.
Well, according to The Grand Comics Database, the first issue of the four-issue miniseries shipped in 2023, and the final issue earlier this year. The collection, which is how I read it—and, given the long gap between individual issues, was probably the best way to read it—was released in September. This means you have now had at least two or three months to read it in its final collected form, if you are so inclined, and thus I feel less guilty about spoiling some aspects of the book. (If you haven't read it yet though, I would recommend you not read this post but instead go get a copy from your local comic shop or bookstore. Or library. Or Hoopla.)
So now permit me to point at pages of the book and shout, "Look! Look at this!"
Metaphorically.
1.) Batman appears. This is the first appearance of Batman in Grampa's book, a big panel at the bottom of page five. It is about as perfect an image of Batman as one can imagine.
Here, he is seen through the eyes of someone who has flicked a light switch only to find the figure standing there where there shouldn't be anyone. Backlit, the figure is just a big, scary shape, the shape of a humanoid bat—or, at the very least, the iconic shape of the Batman, a character who, artist Paul Pope once memorably said, dresses up as his own logo.
Pure black with no detail visible, that's all Batman is here. He's instantly recognizable, but as dark, mysterious and scary as he can be. It's an indelible image, one that reminds me of a few panels from Frank Miller and David Mazzucchelli's "Year One" story arc: That longshot of Batman running along the rooftops with his cape flaring out like wings or that panel of him standing in front of the smoking hole in the wall wherein only the white of his eyes is visible in the silhouette, the panel where he announces, "Ladies and gentlemen. You have eaten well."
Grampa is, obviously, off to a good start.
Please note too the contrast between the Batman figure, a caped and costumed character of fantasy, with the mundane setting of a rundown hallway, with the barrel, the exposed bricks, the wires and the pipes. This is like seeing the monster you might have imagined in your attic or basement as a child.
2.) "It was bait." DC has been publishing Batman comics for 87 years now, and stories featuring the character have been repeatedly adapted into every conceivable media during that time. I've been personally reading them for about 37 of those years. Which is to say there have been a lot of Batman stories, and I've experienced a lot of them.
The most immediate example that springs to mind is from Paul Pope's 2006 Batman: Year 100 (There's Pope's name again. He drew one of the several variant covers for the first issue of this series, which may be in part why he is on my mind at the moment).
In that comic, a future Batman briefly dons fake vampire teeth in order to make himself look scarier than usual to a criminal...you know, a member of that superstitious and cowardly lot that Batman decided to dress up like a bat in order to frighten.
Here, there's a strange scream. In the panel immediately following the one I posted first, a scream comes from out of an open doorway, Grampa, and perhaps letterer John Workman using a big, long, strangled AAAAHHHHHRG to fill the background of the panel.
Presumably, this is the man who turned on the light only to see a big, humanoid bat standing in the basement hallway reacting to the sight.
The bad guys, identifiable by their ski masks and knives, go down the stairs to investigate. They see the man who had turned on the light huddled with another man on the floor and, when one of them asks why they screamed, the man responds, "We...we didn't scream."
That panel is followed by the page above. "It wasn't a scream," Batman says in the narration. "It was bait."
So, it appears that in order to draw the bad guys to him, Batman himself let out a strange, unearthly scream.
That's...weird. And cool. And scary. And, of course, not something I had seen him do before.
3.) Crytoon and the original rogues. As much fun as it would have been to see an artist as specific a sensibility as Grampa drawing The Joker, The Penguin and other familiar Batman rogues—especially in a standalone work like this, where he would be free to redesign them as drastically as he did his Batman—it was refreshing that Grampa chose to create all-new villains for the story.
In the backmatter, he says that he would like to see future creators use these villains in their own Batman comics, and one it is easiest to imagine showing up in a DCU comic is Crytoon, seen above. The photo negative-like look is obviously striking, and the red of blood sure stands out against it.
So, what's his deal...? He's obsessed with a very old cartoon from the dawn of animation (also called Crytoon), and he emulates such cartoonish violence...although when he hits his victims with a hammer, they don't just see birds flying around their heads while a bump rises from their scalp. They just die.
When Batman first encounters him, the Dark Knight enters a room where Crytoon is sitting in a chair and crying, watching one of those cartoons projected onto the wall. In it, the cartoon character is hitting another with a big mallet. Scattered on the ground are childish drawings of figures hitting one another with hammers. Grampa draws a great panel where Batman reflexively strikes that very classic, very batman pose, where he wraps himself defensively in his cape, and we see the cartoon projected across the cape.
And then we get the shot above.
Crytoon takes a hammer to Batman, and while the first blow glances off our hero's helmet, the next few are among the most violent I've seen. In one panel, Crytoon jams the top, flat part of the hammer into Batman's face, and in the next he strikes him on the back of the head, causing Batman to violently spit blood.
There are a couple of other quite colorful villains, plus The Virgin, who seems to occupy a morally ambiguous, Catwoman-like role, and while they are all fairly creepy, I think Crytoon is the most likely to be seen somewhere (Although I guess we shouldn't count out Little Joker, who is pretty much just what he sounds like).
Now, while Crytoon gets an awful lot of panel-time, he might not seem like a character ready to be a regular Batman villain. But then, neither did, say Grant Morrison's Professor Pyg, who similarly seemed a one-off, and has appeared over and over again...and even made it into a cartoon series!
Since there's relatively little incentive for a creator to create a brand-new villain just to hand it over to DC, it seems many modern creators are reluctant to create them, which I guess is why when someone like Morrison does so, other creators are eager to use them, rather than make up their own.
4.) A genuinely attractive Bruce Wayne. The above image, in which we see Batman in the cave after his fight with Crytoon, telling Alfred of his plans to "kill off" Bruce Wayne so he can focus more on being Batman, is our first look at Grampa's Bruce.
While this image might not be the best example from the book—there are later, better images of him in buisness suits, for example—I was struck by the fact that Gargoyle of Gotham is the first Batman comic I've ever read in which Bruce Wayne actually looks attractive.
I mean, maybe I'm not the best judge of these things. But I know that within the comics (and movies, and cartoons, and so on), Bruce Wayne is supposed to be very handsome, but I've never actually seen a comics artist convey that.
More often than not, since I've been reading regularly, Bruce Wayne is usually just depicted as a tall, broad-shouldered, square-jawed bodybuilder type. His huge body ripples with muscles, but physically, he just looks like a generic superhero guy, indistinguishable from Superman save for his hairline. (Of course, the World's Finest do canonically look a lot alike, as there was a period wherein they would regularly disguise themselves as one another.)
Grampa's Bruce, by contrast, looks fit and athletic without being over-muscled. His face has expression and personality. His eyes are clever, alive and piercing. And his hair is thick, longer-than-usual and a bit messy.
I didn't watch the Robert Pattison-starring Batman movie—no offense to Pattison, but I think I might have just seen all the Batman movies I need to at this point—but I wondered to what degree Grampa's Bruce Wayne might have been inspired by Pattison's Wayne. From the images I've seen of him in the movie, his hair at least suggests that of Grampa's Wayne, and this Bruce Wayne's face looks more Pattison-esque than the standard, square-headed Bruce of the comics and cartoons.
5.) The bit with the cake was cute. Batman Comics With Alfred > Batman Comics Without Alfred.
While investigating Crytoon, Batman sends Alfred on a mission which involves his acting skills, and visiting with a little old lady who feeds him delicious cake. They debrief while Batman is speeding around in Grampa's particular version of the Batmobile.
I love that a) Alfred is able to sneak something into the Batmobile that Batman doesn't even notice until the moment of most dramatic impact, b) that Alfred has packed Batman a little snack, as a parent might a child, and, c) that Alfred is very much not onboard with the plan to kill of Bruce Wayne, and makes a subtle argument in his little note here, referring to Batman as "Bruce Wayne".
I still can't believe DC let Tom King kill Alfred off...and that no one has brought him back yet, no matter how contrived a story resurrecting him might be.
6.) Batman takes an anvil to the head. Speaking of things I've never seen in a Batman comic, I don't think I've ever seen anyone drop an anvil on his head, as Crytoon does above (That's him in the big mascot hat, having disguised himself in order to ambush Batman).
Not even in 2000's Superman & Bugs Bunny, which seems like the most obvious comic in which a Justice Leaguer might catch an anvil to the head. (I just checked my collection of that series, 2017's DC/Looney Tunes 100-Page Supe Spectacular #1, and the only character who gets hit with an anvil in it is Mr. Mxyzptlk.)
7.) Moth-er is scarier than Killer Moth...or "Charaxes". Now that's a scary moth-themed Batman villain...!
8.) This girl giving the bad guys the double birds. There are no Robins in Gargoyle of Gotham, but Grampa does give Batman young allies whose name begins with the letter "R". These are the Ratz, and they will, by narrative's end, become a bit more Robin-like. (And that's "Ratz" with a "Z"; please don't confuse them with these guys.)
As Batman follows clues that lead him to a big conspiracy at the heart of the book, one that involves the very creation of the Batman persona, he ends up in a room full of cultists in cloaks, their masked master sitting on a throne and occasionally pumping the Dark Knight full of electricity.
Batman is getting his ass kicked (which Grampa's Batman does a lot; his brand of badassedness seems to be not that he can take any foe, but that he keeps getting back up when he's bludgeoned with hammers or anvils or blown up or whatever).
A few of the cultists throw off their masks and robes and reveal themselves as infiltrators. They rescue Batman, throwing him out the same clock face he had earlier smashed through in order to make an entrance. As you can see, one of them, the young woman, takes a moment to give the bad guys the double birds as they escape.
9.) Little Joker? Also terrifying. So, how do you make The Joker scarier...? Dude started as a playing card-themed gangster, evolved into a killer clown, then a serial killer clown with an astronomical body count and is now something of a slasher movie character.
Well, what if he was a little kid...?
When Crytoon is on the run, he's discovered in hiding by a creepy little boy who tells dark jokes. Crytoon draws him the above picture and dubs him "Little Joker".
It's not entirely clear if there's a normal Joker in the world of this comic or not (the rest of the classic rogues gallery gets nodded at in an unlikely way near the end), but it's easy to see how this pint-sized version might scare the bejeezus out of one. Like, imagine finding him giggling at you from across a dark room...
I realize I'm just talking about the surface-level cool shit in this book, but it's worth noting that this character is presented as something of a parallel to the traumatized and violent Bruce Wayne we see in flashbacks set on the night of and just after the murder of his parents. At this point, Little Joker even resembles Little Bruce.
Once again, this is something I've never seen in a Batman comic...or anywhere else, actually.
In short order, Batman is in the streets with The Ratz, wearing a costume made of coats, knives and clothes scavenged from a lost and found, held together with tape and straps and wielding a pair of hammers.
12.) Little Joker as a weapon. The battle scene at the climax sees Crytoon returning to Gotham to take on the bad guys in his own, exceedingly more violent way. By this point, he has Little Joker in tow, and the pair rush into the fight, Little Joker perched on Crytoon's shoulder.
Crytoon uses Little Joker in such a manner in this scene, literally throwing him like a weapon in one panel, and then grabbing him by the leg (Sound effect? "GRAB") and then swinging him at a foe.
You'll notice I'm not sharing it with you here (the image above is the reaction of a superstitious, cowardly criminal reacting to seeing this new Batman lurking on a rooftop across the street from him). That's because it is such a big moment, and has such a big impact, that I don't want to risk spoiling the moment for a reader, even though I did say you should read the book before reading the post.
Now get off the Internet and go read Gargoyle of Gotham if you still haven't done so yet, despite my admonishments to do so.

















No comments:
Post a Comment