But then I saw some discussion on Bluesky at, um, 3 a.m. on Saturday morning, which got me thinking about the Avengers as I lay in bed, waiting to fall back asleep. So, I decided to put those thoughts into a post.
The initial post I saw was from Bob "MovieBob" Chipman, reacting to someone else's post. The initial post began with "I need to know what 30 year old white guy made up the rumor Iron Man was a C-List Marvel hero before the MCU..."
Chipman responded with his age (45) and pointed out that it wasn't just Iron Man who wasn't an A-Lister, saying that The Avengers were B-List at best "until the 2000s when the book/concept was rebooted as 'Marvel's Justice League'".
I am assuming the initial poster was rather young, given the way he used "30 year old". Scrolling through my feed, I saw a few more exchanges related to these, talking about the relative unpopularity of Iron Man and The Avengers vs. Marvel's other characters, particularly in the 1980s and 1990s. (And one poster pointing out that even if Iron Man wasn't Marvel's most popular character, he did manage to carry a solo title for some 30 years, which is cetainly more than most Avengers managed.)
It reminded me that, in 1996, Iron Man, Captain America and the rest of The Avengers (and the Fantastic Four) were so relatively unpopular that Marvel not only didn't know what to do with them, but they even gave up trying for a bit, giving them to Image Comics for a year and letting hotshots Jim Lee and Rob Liefeld do their versions of the characters for a while.
And that, when Marvel was launching their Ultimate line a few years later, the title "Avengers" was apparently considered so unmarketable that the Ultimate Avengers book wasn't actually titled Ultimate Avengers, but The Ultimates instead.
•As for a personal anecdote regarding the pre-movie popularity of Iron Man, way back in 2000 or so I was working at an altweekly newspaper in Columbus and, at the suggestions of my local comic shop manager Gib Bickel, I interviewed a pair of Columbus-based creators who had both recently started working for Marvel, Sean McKeever, who was writing some issues of The Incredible Hulk, and Keron Grant, who was drawing Iron Man.
When interviewing Grant at his home, he showed me some Fantastic Four sketches he had done—I remember him telling me that his take on Mister Fantastic was to make his movements seem more dangerous, like those of a cobra—and I, a longtime DC reader who was just barely beginning to dabble in the Marvel Universe, asked if Fantastic Four was really a bigger book.
It was, Grant said, bigger than Iron Man.
It was, Grant said, bigger than Iron Man.
•If it was the movies that made Iron Man and The Avengers popular, it's probably worth noting (for younger folks who weren't around or weren't paying attention back then), that it was those characters' very unpopularity that made them available for what became Marvel Studios to make movies with them in the first place.
Marvel had, of course, already signed away the rights to make movies featuring all of their popular characters to other studios before getting around to the likes of Iron Man. Blade was the first character to actually have his film hit the big screen (well, second), but various studios had already snapped up the rights to The Punisher, Spider-Man, The X-Men, The Hulk, The Fantastic Four, Daredevil and Ghost Rider. Hell, Universal even acquired the rights to Namor, although they obviously never did anything with him.
The characters that appeared in what became the first phase of the Marvel Cinematic Universe, then—Iron Man, Captain America, Thor, Nick Fury, Black Widow, Hawkeye, Scarlet Witch, Quicksilver—were the ones that were essentially left over after the major studios picked the characters they wanted to try and build movies around. (Hulk, of course, got shoe-horned into 2012's The Avengers, after two attempts at a solo film apparently didn't make as much money or lead to a franchise the way Universal had hoped).
Luckily, all of those characters were associated with Marvel's Avengers team, which made assembling them into a coherent, inter-movie "universe" a bit easier than if the studio had the guys who built "The Marvel Cinematic Universe" actually had their pick of characters and were trying to build a filmic universe in which, say, Spider-Man, The X-Men and The Fantastic Four were the pillars. (It helped too, I suppose, that Mark Millar and Bryan Hitch's 2002-2007 The Ultimates provided a very recent example of what a 21st century Hollywood take on the Avengers might look like...right down to the casting, although Samuel L. Jackson as Fury was ultimately the only suggestion of Millar's they took).
Well, no, "luckily" isn't really the right word. Those characters were all available and all associated because of how relatively unpopular The Avengers brand was compared to that of the rest of the Marvel characters.
•Beyond the discussion of Iron Man and the Avengers' popularity, I was also intrigued with that bit about the team only getting popular when Marvel tried to make them their answer to DC's Justice League, adding their most popular characters like Spider-Man and Wolverine to the line-up.
This was, of course, when writer Brian Michael Bendis and artist David Finch ended the long-running Avengers title with the "Disassembled" arc in 2004 and then launched the New Avengers title in 2005.
This was, of course, when writer Brian Michael Bendis and artist David Finch ended the long-running Avengers title with the "Disassembled" arc in 2004 and then launched the New Avengers title in 2005.
I remember the idea of the team being Marvel's Justice League quite clearly, as the story was bandied about in the online fan press of the time, with Bendis talked about a meeting in which he, Millar, then Editor-in-Chief Joe Quesada and presumably others were discussing it (Bendis had said something in interviews about how Millar was going to write it, but he wanted to, as Millar had already gotten The Ultimates and the upcoming Civil War).
This is the part that really kept me up the other night/morning. I was stuck on the idea that if Marvel's original plan was to do some kind of JLA take on the Avengers, they really half-assed it with Bendis' New Avengers. Because, ultimately, the line-up was just the publisher's two most popular characters (Spider-Man and Wolverine), two token Avengers (Captain America and Iron Man), two characters that Bendis just really liked (Luke Cage and Spider-Woman) and two characters friends of his had created (The Sentry and Echo*).
•Of course, Marvel's real answer to the Justice League was never The Avengers. It was the Fantastic Four.
I mean, Stan Lee has always been pretty up front about the fact that the FF—and through it, the entirety of the Marvel Universe—was a reaction to the success DC was seeing with their Justice League comics when the team debuted in 1960. (I last read a version of this story in Lee's introduction to a JLA/Avengers trade and posted about it here.)
After a golf game during which National/DC publisher Jack Liebowitz bragged to Lee's boss Martin Goodman about how well the comics featuring the new super-team were selling, Goodman asked Lee to come up with a superhero team of their own. And Lee came up with the FF...with a lot of quite obvious help from Jack Kirby, as is evident in the FF's resemblance to his prior team of adventurers in matching suits, The Challengers of the Unknown.
The Avengers, who came around a few years later in 1963, actually looked a bit more like the Justice League in one respect, though: It was a super-team made up of pre-existing characters with their own titles or features. Which meant The Hulk, Iron Man, Thor and Ant-Man and The Wasp...with Kirby and Joe Simon's old pre-Marvel character Captain America soon dusted off and added to the line-up, not unlike Lee and Kirby's usage of Carl Burgos' The Human Torch (or at least his name and design) and then Bill Everett's Namor in the pages of Fantastic Four.
The Avengers, who came around a few years later in 1963, actually looked a bit more like the Justice League in one respect, though: It was a super-team made up of pre-existing characters with their own titles or features. Which meant The Hulk, Iron Man, Thor and Ant-Man and The Wasp...with Kirby and Joe Simon's old pre-Marvel character Captain America soon dusted off and added to the line-up, not unlike Lee and Kirby's usage of Carl Burgos' The Human Torch (or at least his name and design) and then Bill Everett's Namor in the pages of Fantastic Four.
•Just as a thought exercise, though: If Marvel had made an Avengers line-up more similar to the Justice League, what might that have looked like, exactly?
I mean, say it's 1960-1961, Lee gets his directive from Goodman and, rather than creating a new super-team from scratch with Kirby, he looks around for pre-existing characters to team-up, Justice League style...? What sort of Avengers line-up might we have seen?
I guess it would have been Namor, The Human Torch, Captain America and...maybe Toro and Bucky? Whichever two or four pre-Marvel superheroes were the next most popular after those guys? I guess it would therefore resemble The Invaders or one of Marvel's retroactive Golden Age teams, huh?
I mean, say it's 1960-1961, Lee gets his directive from Goodman and, rather than creating a new super-team from scratch with Kirby, he looks around for pre-existing characters to team-up, Justice League style...? What sort of Avengers line-up might we have seen?
I guess it would have been Namor, The Human Torch, Captain America and...maybe Toro and Bucky? Whichever two or four pre-Marvel superheroes were the next most popular after those guys? I guess it would therefore resemble The Invaders or one of Marvel's retroactive Golden Age teams, huh?
Or maybe something more insane, like, and I'm just guessing here without checking the dates, but, like, Namor, The Human Torch, Captain America, The Rawhide Kid, Sgt. Fury, Millie the Model and Fin Fang Foom...? (Admit it; you're intrigued).
What if we gave Lee and company, say, five years to fill the Marvel Universe with new heroes, and then assemble from them a Justice League-like Avengers line-up, consisting of their most popular solo heroes. What might such a team look like circa1966?
Maybe Namor, Captain America, Spider-Man, Doctor Strange, Nick Fury, Daredevil and The Hulk...? Could be interesting...! (I'm just guessing here, obviously; I have no idea if Strange, Fury and Daredevil were outselling the likes of Thor and Iron Man at that point or not.)
And what if Marvel did it today? (Interestingly, Marvel's current Avengers book seems to be doing a new New Avengers take at the moment, with Spider-Man, Wolverine, Captain America, Luke Cage, a token female character and a Superman-style character on the line-up).
I have no idea who Marvel's current most popular/iconic superheroes plus their Martian Manhunter equivalent might be at the moment, and now that we don't get to see sales figures, I guess I can't look up which six characters have the best-selling solo books.
If I had to guess based at a glance at the December solicits, I would guess we would be looking at a team like Spider-Man, Wolverine, Deadpool, The Infernal Hulk, Venom, Daredevil, Jean Grey and I guess The Vision as the Martian Manhunter character...? (Although Thor, Iron Man or Captain America would also fulfill the Guy Who Is Usually On The Team role that J'onn plays on the Justice League, and have the benefit of being more popular, too.)
I just picked Jean Grey at random as a female character. Spider-Woman, Black Cat and Jessica Jones are also female characters with titles solicited for December though.
If I had to guess based at a glance at the December solicits, I would guess we would be looking at a team like Spider-Man, Wolverine, Deadpool, The Infernal Hulk, Venom, Daredevil, Jean Grey and I guess The Vision as the Martian Manhunter character...? (Although Thor, Iron Man or Captain America would also fulfill the Guy Who Is Usually On The Team role that J'onn plays on the Justice League, and have the benefit of being more popular, too.)
I just picked Jean Grey at random as a female character. Spider-Woman, Black Cat and Jessica Jones are also female characters with titles solicited for December though.
•Oh, and as for the title of this post, when I was grocery shopping this week, I noticed a display stand in the cereal aisle with Kellog's Avengers: Doomsday-branded cereal. There were multiple boxes, each of which seemed to feature two characters. Looking at the photo I took, the two boxes in it feature an Avengers character in the foreground and an X-Men character in the background.
The cereal, by the way, is chocolate...is that because chocolate is a "dark" flavor, which ties into the concept of "Doomsday"...? I don't know. I would have assumed an Avengers breakfast cereal to be something brighter, and with an alliance of colorful marshmallows representing the various heroes. But then, this isn't an Avengers in general cereal, but an Avengers: Doomsday specific one...
•It's been 14 years since Avengers came out, and, in those years, Marvel teams The Guardians of the Galaxy, The Eternals, The Fantastic Four and The Thunderbolts/New Avengers have all gotten Marvel Studios movies, and they seem to be in the process of starting a brand-new X-Men team while reviving the original one for what I presume is a last hurrah in Doomsday.
I am still waiting on The Defenders and The Champions movies.
(Now let's talk C-listers...)
*Or "Ronin", I guess. I read these comics, but it has been about 25 years now, so my memories of them aren't that great...and my memories of fan press articles about those comics and their making are even dimmer at this point. So correct me if I'm wrong, but I believe the original plan was that the mysterious new "Ronin" character was going to turn out to be Daredevil in disguise—Bendis was writing Daredevil at the time, and the character fits the initial all-star team line-up concept—but that plan was changed when it became too obvious who Ronin was, and Echo was substituted for Daredevil...even though it was pretty clear that Ronin was mean to be a man rather than a woman. (Artist Finch was the sort with very distinct "man" and "woman" character designs, all of the latter being much smaller and slimmer than all of the former). And Hawkeye Clint Barton was Ronin for a bit too, when he stopped being dead., but I'm uncertain now of who was Ronin when...It was certainly Barton who was Ronin in the Cinematic Universe...









No comments:
Post a Comment