Wednesday, January 14, 2009

Weekly Haul: January 14th

Action Comics #873 (DC Comics) And thus concludes the “New Krypton” epic, with a final chapter entitled “Birth of a Nation” (oy). It’s a somewhat unsatisfying conclusion, given there’s no real resolution, simply the arrival of a new status quo, which comes pretty quickly on the heels of the new status quo established at the beginning of the story. Now instead of a city full of Superman in the Arctic Cricle, there’s a planet full of Superman in the solar system.

This chapter was written by Geoff Johns, and while it’s fairly Geoff Johns-y, I was impressed in several places with how Grant Morrison-y it felt. There’s Luthor speaking of “the men with kryptonite hearts,” and a damn clever magical tactic for removing the powers from Supermen. (My hat, if I wore one, would be off on that latter bit, Mr. Johns).

On the negative side, the superheroes filling out the squad sent to pacify the Kryptonians seemed poorly chosen (I’m not sure how Stargirl or the Hawks survived, for example, nor why The Thunderbolt couldn’t have stripped the whole population of its powers, but whatever).

And, just to let us know that this is an important story, a minor character from the ‘90s gets killed in the epilogue. Or maybe just super-lobotomized or something—he has two holes drilled into his forehead via heat-vision, which sure looks like a deathblow to me.



Amazing Spider-Man #583 (Marvel Comics) This issue of Marvel’s flagship Spider-Man comic has been getting a ton of mainstream media attention, and has reportedly generated some crazy eBay sales prices and lines out the door in some comic shops. And no wonder—it features a story about the current status of the relationship between Peter Parker and Daily Bugle staffer Betty Brant!

This is also the Obama issue, although the president-elect is relegated to a five-page back-up by Zeb Wells and Todd Nauck. Six pages if you count the cover separating the back-up from the main story, which is the same image on the Obama variant by Phil Jiminez, a crudely drawn image of Obama giving an idiot grin and vanquished political rival John McCain’s favorite hand gesture while Spider-Man takes a picture of the back of his head. Only on the inside version, there’s a red credits box in the lower right hand corner, and, in the upper left hand corner, another box saying, “Marvel Bonus Back-Up Feature!” Ha ha, the book is actually $3.99, so we’re paying an extra buck for these “bonus” six pages.

Marvel Comics is, of course, a business, and slapping Obama’s image on a variant cover and hastily assembling a five-page back-up—overnight, based on the skill evidenced in the final product—to ship the week of the inauguration was a pretty smart business move. In public relations alone, the move was well worth whatever they paid the creators for it.

But it is certainly crass, and more than a little depressing. Or, as Tom Spurgeon noted, gross. I’d encourage you to go read Spurgeon’s paragraph about the book in its full context, but he rightly noted that it would have been nicer “if a company that has concentrated on story the last decade or so to astounding benefit made a solid comic out of the event rather than a kind of cruddy-looking, cynical one.”

Having read those five pages now, “gross” seems like a pretty good way to sum the whole thing up, and I won’t argue with “kind of cruddy-looing” or “cynical” either.

So, here’s the story: Peter Parker, freelance photographer for Front Line newspaper, visits Washington DC for the inauguration, and just as Obama arrives, a second presidential limo crashes into the first, and out steps another Obama. Holy crap, two Obamas!

Wanted criminal Spider-Man swings in to the circle of blasé, unarmed secret service agents and suggests they ask the two Obamas a question only the real Barack Obama would know. As the Obamas argue, it becomes clear that one of them has never heard of the popular American sport basketball, revealing that he thinks it involves a helmet, and is played on a basketball diamond.

The imposter revealed, he transforms back into the Chameleon, and Spidey punches him out, accepts his daps from the real Obama, and then perches atop the Washington monument to complete his photo assignment.

I really like Todd Nauck’s art, but, as I mentioned before, he’s a pretty poor choice for this particular assignment, and his art has never looked worse than under colorist Frank D’Armata, who provides a slick, sick, hyper-real shading that works against Nauck’s cartoonier style.

Wells is a little more hit or miss with me, but in general I’m a fan of his work—he’s got a solid rep as a fun, funny writer, and there’s at least one genuinely clever joke here. But that’s all there really is—a clever joke, a couple of dumb jokes and the end. (I guess I don’t know the Chameleon’s secret origin—is he an alien or something? How come he’s never heard of basketball?).

As Spurgeon noted, this seems like a disappointing cash-in from a company that could do much, much better—hell, they’ve assembled some extremely creative and talented individuals who always do better than this—and give that the Marvel Universe has revolved around the policies of their version of the United States’ federal government for much of the last decade, this story seems extremely perfunctory. Obama co-narrated Secret Invasion #8, for Chrisakes…no one could think of anything better to do with him than this?

It didn’t even rate a 22-page story? I suppose there were some timing issues to be considered—Obama only won the election about two months ago—but this sure felt last-minute rather than last-month. A story about Spidey visiting Washington D.C. and foiling The Chameleon’s plot to impersonate the new president could certainly have been started before the polls closed.

As is, this story seems oddly unimportant, a weird little gimmick attached, ad-like, to the back of a normal Spider-Man comic. It’s basically just one of those old Hostess ads that used to run in comics, only five times longer and 500 times more crass and depressing.

Back to the bulk of the book, this is a little bit better than the similarly disappointing Stephen Colbert/Spider-Man crossover, which at least featured a much better cover. That creatively bankrupt, cynical, “Hey media, look at us! Look at us!” story may have featured a much better cover than this one, but it also came attached to the conclusion of a storyline, so newcomers could be extremely unlikely to know or care what was going on.

Waid and company’s story isn’t necessarily a great jumping on point, but at least it’s a stand-alone, done-in-one competently accomplished, and unlikely to confuse the hell out of new readers the way a story about Venom, Anti-Venom and the Thunderbolts fighting a bullet-ridden Spider-Man might.

Narrator Betty Brant talks about her friend Peter Parker, and how unreliable he is, because he won’t tell her or any of his friends, family or loved ones that he’s actually Spider-Man (he comes across like a bit of asshole because of his insistence of keeping this a secret, even from his aunt, actually). She takes him speed-dating, and she’s sure he’s planning a surprise birthday part for her the following night, but he’s not.

Waid writes nice Spider-Man fight chatter, and handles the soap opera elements of the plot just fine. Spidey seems like an unlikable dick, but that’s hardly Waid’s fault—it’s just where Marvel wants the character right now. Kitson and Farmer are both quite accomplished artists, and while Kitson’s style has never been one that I was overly excited about, there’s nothing technically wrong with it. It looks worse than the last time I saw it, but that has more to do with the coloring, which gives everyone the over-textured look of mannequins squashed into a 2D environment.

Now if you’ll excuse me, I’m going to go take a shower, as this whole Obama/Spider-Man thing makes me feel really, really dirty.


Booster Gold #16 (DC) Because I demanded it! Time-traveling Booster Gold meets up with Hans Von Hammer, The Hammer of Hell! Well, because I demanded it, or because writer/artist Dan Jurgens also thought it would be cool to work the Enemy Ace into the series. One.

This is part two of a storyline Jurgens is calling “Reality Lost,” and there’s some connective tissue to the previous chapter—including Booster’s little sister and little robot helper looking for him, while he looks for a maguffin—but it also serves as a decent enough done-in-one introducing Booster Gold readers to Enemy Ace, whose Showcase Presents collection I highly recommend.

Jurgens does a pretty good Enemy Ace, even if he never mentions “twin spandaus” or the “skies being the killers of us all” at any point, and together with Norm Rapmund he does a fairly Joe Kubert-ian Enemy Ace. (Check out this preview at Newsarama to see what I mean). Stories like this are what I find so exciting about the premise of the new incarnation of Booster Gold; as a time-traveler, he has access to the entire history of the DC Universe, giving the creators free reign when it comes to stories, characters and settings to play with.


Captain Britain and MI13 #8 (Marvel) This ends the much-too-long story about the demon Plotka making a Mindless Ones factory that runs on the fantasies of human victims. It’s been a quite decent read, but has taken a lot longer than the premise really warranted—in the 1970s or ‘80s, this would have been a one or two-issue storyline, tops. There was no great pay-off at the end either—although Pete Wisdom’s speech about personal responsibility while slashing his way through a series of fantasies using a magic sword was kinda neat—and I would probably be thinking of dropping the title at this point, if it weren’t for the last page.

It features Marvel’s Dracula, dabbing the blood off his stupid-looking moustache while standing on the balcony of his castle on the moon, telling an underling, “get me Doctor Doom.”

So I’m fairly certain Captain Britain and MI13 #9 is going to be fairly awesome.



Final Crisis #6 (DC) The story’s not quite over yet, but I think it’s safe to declare Grant Morrison’s big, DC superhero crossover Final Crisis a complete failure.

Too strong? Let’s check out the first page here. There’s Superman in the first panel, carrying on a conversation with one of the at least three Brainiac 5’s in the 31st century. When we last saw Superman, he was traveling through alternate realities with various versions of himself in the Grant Morrison-written Superman Beyond #1. He was simultaneously in the 31st Century in Final Crisis: Legion of Three Worlds, a story whose only connection to Final Crisis prior to this panel was the fact that it had the words “Final” and “Crisis” in its title.

Superman Beyond #2, which concludes that side story, has yet to see release; Legion of Three Worlds is only about half over. This is set after those stories.

I assume your average reader will have no problem filling in the blanks here—I don’t know if anyone following these stories actually thinks that maybe Superman will die in one of those side stories, for example (And if they do, well, that’s kind of adorable, isn’t it?)—and if this were a writer who wasn’t Grant Morrison, then this might not be that big of a deal.

But this is Grant Morrison. He’s the guy who wrote DC One Million, a company-wide crossover that twisted through hundreds of centuries in time and touched every book DC was then publishing in some form or another, the storyline itself wended through many of them, important story beats happening where they were least expected, and the entire, gargantuan thing synched up just perfectly.

He’s also the guy who wrote DC’s Seven Soldiers event, which when read as intended—i.e. as it came out, I don’t think it works as well experienced in trade collections—was a story in which the events, characters, settings and props of seven individual miniseries moved sideways through one another and linked up just so without necessarily demanding you read each one in any particular chronological order. It was a crossover, but it was a very peculiar sort of crossover, a hands-off one where the characters didn’t even really know they were in a crossover, where only the writer and the reader had the full picture, looking like gods down upon a storyscape the characters couldn’t even comprehend because they were so close to it.

In other words, Grant Morrison knows what he’s doing with these sorts of stories, and he’s not doing it right this time. The trains are not running on time, connections are being missed. Is it Morrison’s fault? DC editorial? Does it matter? Not to readers. In final trade format, maybe this will matter less—will Superman Beyond be collected with Final Crisis, though?—but as experienced as an event, it’s a failure. Hell, it doesn’t even look nice; here the single artist who became two art teams has now become three art teams, all with styles that are less than compatible and aren’t deployed in any logical fashion anyway (I like all three of those team okay, mind you, but my favorite team was that of Doug Mahnke and Christian Alamy, left off the cover credits, who also happen to be the fastest of the teams).

So this is the sixth chapter of the seven-part core series, the darkest-before-the-dawn chapter, and a lot of stuff is happening. There are a lot of cool Grant Morrison ideas in here, there are some fairly bad-ass moments of heroes doing cool things, but it’s all strained through the darkness of a world won by Darkseid which, in different circumstances, might seem a stark contrast to DC Comics in general, but given the dark, dreary tone of the DC Universe over the past two or three years, it just seems stale.

This chapter is exceptionally dark and violent, but DC super-comics have been exceptionally dark and violent for years now; what exactly distinguishes this from your average issue of Teen Titans or Justice League of America?

At any rate, things happen. Braniac 5 shows Superman a god macine, capable of translating thoughts into reality. Supergirl and Mary Marvel-possessed-by-an-evil-New-God fight while arguing over which of them is a slut. J.G. Jones reveals what color panties Supergirl is wearing this issue. Tawky Tawny disembowels Kalibak. Shiloh Norman is a white guy for some reason. Most Excellent Superbat reveals his super-power, and it is awesome. Montoya has bleached her hair light brown and maybe she’s white now too. The Atoms have a cool escape plan. Sivana and Luthor start kicking ass. The Flashes prepare to outrace death itself for, like, the fifteenth time since I started reading comics. Superman goes ape-shit with the heat-vision. And, in biggest event of the book, we see the promised “final fate of Batman,” the true ending of “Batman R.I.P.” and, well, it’s a whole bunch of who cares.

Ready?

So Batman makes his way into Darkseid-in-Turpin’s-body’s throne room. He shoots him with the god-killing bullet that had previously killed Orion, and then gets struck by Darkseid’s omega effect in a two-panel spread (this scene is fairly reminiscent of Morrison’s own “Rock Of Ages” arc in JLA, as elements of Darkseid’s take over of Earth have been; in that story, a future Batman obliterates Darkseid’s moonbase slave factory in front of the evil god, and gets omega beam-ed).

When next we see Batman, he looks skeletal and mummified, and Superman is cradling his body.

Oh my God, is Batman dead?! Well, no. DC will do some crazy shit, but they’re not going to kill Batman off, and there’s very little suspense here, given the circumstance of his eath.

For one, Darkseid’s eye beams have various effects, depending on his whim (and that of the writer). They can kill, they can erase someone from existence, they can resurrect the dead, they can teleport, they can transform a person. So Batman’s not necessarily dead just because he got eye-beamed.

The last time a New God got shot with that very same bullet, we were told it warped time, space and, thus, DC continuity. The last time Darkseid died the same thing happened. So if Batman was dead for a panel or two, he may not even be dead anymore.

And then the sky here is red and full of Earths, as it was before the last continuity reboot in Infinite Crisis; clearly another continuity reboot is on its way, as all those alternate Earths aren’t going to stay in the red sky of the DCU indefinitely. So, well, you get the idea.

So that’s Final Crisis by its penultimate issue: Off the rails schedule and thus plot-wise, full of great work from three different art teams that nevertheless don’t compliment one another, and distinctly lacking in any sort of suspense or much in the way of new ideas. Again, if this was anyone but Morrison, it might not seem so disappointing, but with over 180 pages finished, the most exciting new ideas he’s offered have been the idea of the New Gods as Catholic conceptions of demons possessing people, and the Japanese cosplay version of the Justice League.



Super Friends #11 (DC) I don’t much care for this title, as it’s really and truly a kids comic, rather than an all-ages comics (that is, it’s created specifically for little kids at the exclusion of those who aren’t little kids). That’s not a complaint, mind you, there are certainly more than enough comics written for thirtysomethings, but compared to other Johnny DC titles and the Marvel Adventures line, this one kind of stands out as young-ages instead of all-ages.

This is, in fact, only my second issue of the series, and I blame that entirely on J. Bone, who has produced this fantastic cover of the Super Friends all wearing Batman-ified versions of their costumes. The final cover includes the text, “Who is the myster Bat-Squad!? You won’t believe the answer!” I assume that it’s the other Super Friends, and, guess what, it is! I do believe the answer! You were totally wrong about me, cover blurb-writer!

Also of interest, this is illustrated by Chynna Clugston of Blue Monday, Scooter Girl and Queen Bee. This isn’t her first work for Johnny DC books—I recall her drawing a Mad Mod issue of Teen Titans Go! and at least one issue of the Legion book—but it is certainly the most depressing one.

Clugston is an incredible talent—both as an artist and a writer—and it just bums me the hell out that her talent is being squandered drawing in the style of the Mattel toy line this books based on (a design style that, by the way, I loathe). There are only a few panels in which Clugston’s own art style manages to poke through, mostly in the characters’ eyes and expressions. This is the only character that even looks all that much like she emerged from the end of Clugston’s pencil:
You know what might be a better use of Clugston’s talents at DC? Having her pencil anything. Oh man, could you imagine a Clugston written and drawn Teen Titans series? Even—or perhaps especially—a stand alone, “Sure Chynna, do whatever the hell you want with ‘em,” miniseries?

As for this comic, written by Sholly Fisch, The Super Friends are in the midst of running down the Royal Flush Gang when Bat-Mite shows up, and prevents them from doing so, so that Batman can do it himself.

They argue that it would be harder for Batman to do so by himself, since he lacks their powers, so Bat-Mite takes away all their powers and gives them to Batman. Then Mr. Mxyzptlk shows up, and completely breaks my comic—some pages are apparently missing, and others are printed twice.

The story’s simple enough to follow even with the printing errors though—Mxy causes problems, and at some point Bat-Mite gives the heroes more Batman-like looks, although not the costumes Bone gave ‘em on the cover. Instead, they mostly just get pointy bat-earys, capes and wrist scallops on their old costumes (Aquaman, for example, looks like he’s moussed his hair into bat-ears and tied a blue towl around his neck.

Bat-Mite defeats Mxyzptlk in the usual manner, and then a bunch of other imps show up, leading to a rather inspired conclusion.

I recognized Quisp and Wonder Woman’s leprechaun friend there, but I have no idea who that Flash imp is—the tall one with the glasses and the lightning bolt on his chest.
Anyone out there on the other side of my computer screen know?

There are also some dancing puppets, which Aquaman demonstrates. Step four is “Now Bat-Mite and Mister Mxyzptlk are ready to make mischief—or just do a dance!

Once completed, they look like this:
I have no idea how Aquaman fit them on over his big, heroic fingers. I had to widen the holes significantly, and I could still barely get them on farther than my knuckles. And I have dainty little blogger hands.



Trinity #33 (DC) This week, twenty-two pages of treading water. Back-up pencil art by Scott McDaniel.

A quick word about a comic I didn't read today

I gave Faces of Evil: Prometheus a flip-through at the shop today. The Grant Morrison JLA run that spawned him remains one of my favorite comic book reading experiences, and I was kinda curious how DC planned to rehab the character after he was so poorly written in Batman: Gotham Knights and subsequent appearances. Essentially, he went from Morrison's conception as a kind of reverse Batman (criminal parents killed by cops, swears vengeance on the forces of law and justice) with Matrix powers (can download skills directly into his brain) to a run-of-the-mill henchman working under the Jeph Loeb-created evil plastic surgeon Hush.

What I saw was a pretty lame attempt at restoration by writer Sterling Gates—there were two Promethei, the original badass one and a more incompetent imposter—and some decent enough art by Federico Dalbochio. So whatever, a pretty run-of-the-mill, not terribly intersting looking comic book.

And then I noticed Anima was in it. I've mentioned her at least once before on EDILW, but for those of you unfamiliar, she was a teenage runaway character heavily influenced in design, fashion and tastes by the popular "alternative" music of her mid-90's origin. She debuted as part of DC's throw-a-bunch-of-new-heroes-at-the-wall-and-see-what-sticks "New Blood" event. She was one of the more sucessful characters from the event, earning a solo series that lasted 16 issues (two more than Gunfire, nowhere near as many as Hitman).

It wasn't the greatest book, and swathes of it don't hold up very well today, but I really liked it while it lasted, and, even looking back today from a 30+ year old's eyes, there are still a lot of admirable things about it. It tackled some tough issues—the heroine's best friend was a lesbian with AIDs, for example—in a way that was lightyears more subtle and effective than what you get in your modern Judd Winick comic.

Speaking of Judd Winick, he pulled Anima out of limbo to have her brutally killed alongside a bunch of other minor characters he didn't create in 2007's Titans East Special #1 (Check the comments section at that link for a few word's from one of Anima's creators about her origins).

So I was pretty surprised to see her in this book, being brutaly killed again.

I didn't follow Winick's new Titans series, because it was a Judd Winick Titans series, so I guess maybe Anima and all those other characters weren't actually killed-killed, just really, really, really, really badly hurt. Well, if Winick didn't finish her off, it looks like Gates does so here—as she gets completely cut in half.

So did DC pluck a minor character forgotten by all but a few fans, violently kill her off to show how bad-ass a villain was and motivate some other heroes to ge revenge in one book, forget about her for a year or so, and then bring her back to violently kill her off again to show how bad-ass another villain is...?

If not admirable, its at least endearing the way DC wholeheartedly embraces its decadence, isn't it?

Tuesday, January 13, 2009

Review: Shrapnel: Aristeia Rising #1


Sometimes high production values can actually do a disservice to a comic, at least in the cases of comics that aren’t actually very good. But when the production values are high, the paper glossy and expensive looking, the lettering expert, the package professional and well-designed and the artwork painted (or painted-looking), it certainly raises one’s expectations, so that if they’re dashed, they seem to get dashed harder than they might if the comic looked as poorly put together as the story and the skill with which its being told.

Shrapnel: Aristeia Rising is a five-part miniseries from Radical Publishing, the new-ish publisher responsible for Hercules: The Thracian Wars and Caliber: First Canon of Justice.

Like those efforts, Shrapnel looks great and has something of a high concept, albeit not one as unusual as Caliber’s “King Arthur set in the Old West.”

In the future, wars will indeed be fought in big, mechanical battle suits just like decades worth of anime had predicted. I believe the word for them is “mechs,” although in this book they’re referred to as “armour.”

The solar system has been more or less populated, by humans presumably all from earth. But “human” means something a little different in this future, as genetic engineering became a reality. “Genotypes” or “Splicers” are the upper class of humanity, those whose parents could afford to be selective in their genetic traits. Everyone else—i.e. people like us—are called “Helots,” and they have menial jobs like garbage collecting and asteroid mining, which is what the characters who seem to be the protagonists do.

I say think because the point-of-view is somewhat indistinct, and the storytelling fairly confused. The book opens with a ten-page battle between a bunch of these battle mechs, using huge machine guns and sonic swords. Someone unidentified is narrating.

On that tenth page, we learn that it was all just a simulation that the marines were involved in. Then we change scenes, zooming in to a bar in a futuristic city in a dome on a planet that isn’t Earth (by book’s end it’s clear that this is actually Venus). As we’re zooming in, the narrator has gone and won’t return; a pair of people are having a conversation we “hear” over the panels doing the zooming-in, each in a different color-coded narration box, Brad Meltzer-style.

This is where we meet our trio of Helot heroes, two ready-to-fight men and Sam, a woman with a mysterious past (including impressive, military-like instincts that she claims to be unaware of).

Meanwhile, the marines visit the president and ask him to surrender his planet—Venus, not Earth—and since he does not, Venus prepares for war, even though they’ve no real army and will likely be slaughtered by the marines. Sam wants to run, her friends sign up, and it ends in another big mech battle, this one clearly between the marines and the Venusian volunteers, who are fighting for freedom.

The credits are reminiscent of the old Virgin Comics credits, with creators who aren’t actually the writer or artist credited. Here, Mark Long and Nick Sagan get top-billing as creators, while an M. Zachary Sherman is the credited writer, and Batus Hutomo the artist. There’s a colorist, Leos “Okita” Ng credited as well, which makes me a little curious about the exact process: The book looks fully painted in most panels—there are a few featuring spaceships or building exteriors that look computer-y—but if a colorist is also credited, then I assume Hutomo didn’t paint the art, or at least not in its finished form.

That art is really nice, by the way, but it doesn’t work as it should. The individual images all look nice, if dark—battlefields, space, spaceships, bars, bunkers, no scene is set anywhere with any decent lighting—but they don’t move right, or synchronize with the dialogue.

The opening battle is confusing, and there are few clues within the design work to indicate where anything is taking place: There are dark, futuristic looking places on every page, but there’s nothing to distinguish the inside of the Octagon (Venus’ eight-sided equivalent of the Pentagon) from the Sam’s quarters, for example.

Worse, there are often times too many words for a single image. A panel will show a marine drill sergeant-y type yelling, his mouth open and his lips contorted to pronounce a particular word, and yet four bubbles of dialogue come out. Two panels later, two marines are illustrated making a similar face, shouting “OO-RAAAH!”, yet seven sentences worth of dialogue are spoken by another character off-panel, while their faces are apparently frozen like that.

Is this nit-picky? I suppose. If these were the only two panels like that, they might not need singled out, but they’re not; time doesn’t quite flow right in many of the panels, and that’s a big problem for a comic book. No matter how good the component writing and art are, if they don’t work in harmony, the comic doesn’t work. These don’t, and thus the comic doesn’t.

Even still, $1.99 gets you the first, 48-page, practically ad-free issue, and God knows there are much worse, much shorter books you can buy, and pay a lot more for the privilege. More info, including a more clear summary than what you’ll find in the book, can be found here.

Monday, January 12, 2009


Far be it from me to question the cover copy of a 34-year-old Marvel comic, but I have a hard time believing anyone asked, let alone demanded that Man-Thing battle Spider-Man, Daredevil, The Thing and Shang-Chi simultaneously.

Sunday, January 11, 2009

This is (actually) a graphic novel: Sara Varon's Chicken and Cat



You are probably (hopefully) aware of the work of Sara Varon, whose Robot Dreams is one of the most heart-breaking comics I’ve ever had emotionally destroy me for an evening (Seriously, it’s right up there with Good-bye Chunky Rice in the How Can Something This Cute Be This Sad? department).

Are you also aware that she’s also broken into the children’s picture book maket, with 2006 book Chicken And Cat (Scholastic Press)? I was not.

Like Robot Dreams, Chicken and Cat deals with the subject of relationships, both the joys and difficulties inherent in them. Unlike Robot Dreams, it’s a much shorter, simpler and ultimately more optimistic story—one that ends rather happily, instead of coming to the fatalistic conclusion that life is like this, and that’s neither good nor bad, it’s just the way it is.

Also like Robot Dreams, it’s completely wordless, yet the thoughts, feelings and even words of the characters are hardly enigmatic. Varon is one of those extremely gifted artists who can take an extremely simply drawing and somehow—magic? Alchemy?—imbue it with clearly communicated, somewhat complex emotions.

Here, for example, is a picture of Cat, looking out the window at an empty lot sealed off by a chain link fence and nestled between a half dozen gray apartment buildings:


This is one of those interesting books that is probably technically comics, although it’s packaged, presented and (most likely) shelved with children’s picture books. It has the shape, size, general format and price point of a kids book, but the contents are simply a series of sequential images. Sometimes the illustrations take up the entire page, with the borders of the pages serving as panels, but a few of them are divided into actual panels, like this sequence:


Cat has just arrived on a bus, carrying a suitcase, and is met by Chicken, who walks him/her/it to his/her/its (their?) apartment. Along the way, Cat notices some facts of urban life, the smile he/she/it had upon first seeing Chicken having evaporated into this expression. (Although in that last panel, Cat may be reacting to the fact that there are dogs that go about on all fours and wear collars and leashes inhabiting the same world that Cat and his/her/its bipedal friend Chicken live in. Varon’s city is kind of funny in that there are both anthropomorphic animals and humans—all around the same size and same peanut-esque shape—and normal animals who don’t walk upright, have thumbs or do human things).

Chicken and Cat spend the day riding around the city on their bikes and visiting the park, and then Cat goes to sleep in his/her/its won room that night (Cat seems to moving in with Chicken, rather than visiting).

The next day they take the F train to Coney Island, where they wear old-timey men’s bathing suits, and hang out at the beach. On the way home, Cat looks at an apartment with that look in his/her/its eyes again, and Chicken notices. So they go and buy a bunch of seeds, plant them, and turn that empty lot across the street into a garden full of flowers and vegetables. Now when Cat looks out that window, with Chicken, cat has the smile he/she/it had on when he/she/it first arrived.

Varon’s work loses nothing by appearing in such a large format. Most of the “panels” are eight inches high and ten inches across, and, rereading it to pay closer attention to her line work, I found the bigger size actually helps a bit. Certainly it makes her characters’ faces easier to read, probably a must given that this is geared towards the youngest readers (at least according to Amazon.com), but it also underlines how simple the artwork is on a technical level, which only makes it more impressive that it is as effective as it is.

Additionally, it really draws attention to the fact that the art is handmade—the dots that serve as the pupils in her character’s eyes, for example, are made with a tight, controlled scribble that keeps them from attaining a perfect orb shape—and only makes it all the warmer.

It feels kinda cheesy saying this—which is why I prefer talking about comics—but this really is a children’s book for all ages. Certainly little kids, less-little kids and grown-ups will all get different things out of it.

I’d certainly not hesitate to recommend it to readers on my side of their adolescence. I think it would probably make a good chaser to Robot Dreams. If Robot Dreams reduces you to tears and melancholy, Chicken and Cat’s brighter, happier ending might serve as a good pick-me-up.

A second Chicken and Cat book, Chicken and Cat Clean Up, is scheduled for release in March.

Saturday, January 10, 2009

Well, at least they're not smoking...




(Image from Ultimatum #2 by Jeph Loeb, David Finch and Danny Miki; I found it at Dirk Deppey's Journalista and cut and pasted it from there because, you know, who buys and reads Jeph Loeb comics these days?)

Friday, January 09, 2009

Who is the new Black Panther? And who cares who she is?

If you read any Marvel comics in the singles format, you've probably seen ads like this:


There's at least one other one as well, asking, "Is Echo The New Black Panther?" and featuring the head of the minor Daredevil character who was in a few issues of New Avengers cut and pasted on top of the female BP figure there.

See, when Black Panther gets relaunched next month—during Black History month, naturally—he will be a she. At least for a while. There's nothing really all that unusual, or even noteworthy, about a superhero being temporarily replaced by another secret identity.

In fact, it happens to just about every hero at one point or another. In some cases, like Batman or Captain America, it seems to happen on some sort of cycle. Heck, this isn't even the first time someone other than T'Challa took up the Black Panther mantle.

What I find interesting about this particular ad campaign, however, is just how random it is.

"Is Echo the new Black Panther?"

Who? Oh, the woman who wore a padded man-suit to be Ronin for a while. No, of course not. Why would she be.

"Is Sue Storm the new Black Panther?"

Sue? No, of course not. Why would she be? She's not even in Marvel continuity until Mark Millar and Bryan Hitch finish their Fantastic Four run, is she?

"Is Monica Rambeau the new Black Panther?"

No. Jesus; are you pulling these names out of a hat?

It's probably unfair of me to say that no one cares simply because I don't care, but I honestly haven't heard anyone outside of these ads discussing who the new lady Black Panther could possibly be. Perhaps I just don't know anyone who reads Black Panther anymore, or read any bloggers who are excited about the next volume of the title, or don't hang around the right message boards anymore (although I do spend significant amounts of each day at Newsarama).

I haven't read Black Panther in a while, although I thought writer Reginald Hudlin turned out some really great scripts during the time I was reading it—the first story arc with John Romita Jr. art, the surprisingly readable "House of M" tie-in, the whole "Black Avengers" arc—but lost interest somewhere around the FF tie-ins, thanks to a combination of ever changing artists and the casual approach to continuity (i.e. the refusal to acknowledge its existence).

But as far back as then—last summer, according to the Grand Comic Book Database—Hudlin was writing scenes in which T'Challa's little sister was questioning her big brother's leadership ability, and her friends were urging her to usurp his throne/position. So every time I see one of these ads, after my first confusion as to why they exist at all or why they're choosing the names and heads they're choosing, I think of T'Challa's sister.

I suppose Marvel could throw a real curve ball and have it be B.P.'s wife Storm, but it strikes me as a really odd and ineffective campaign to drum up interest for a title and a storyline where that no one's much interested.

But of course I don't actually know anything about marketing. For all I know, each of these ads will end up being a different variant cover for Black Panther #1 and it will sell 115,000 units in the direct market.

Thursday, January 08, 2009

Five thoughts on this Obama/Spider-Man comic book thing

As you've probably already heard, President-Elect Barack Obama will be appearing in next week's Amazing Spider-Man #583, and will be appearing on one of the book's several covers. (If you haven't heard, here's the article in USA Today, and here's Newsarama interviewstress Vaneta Roger's article, which includes more salient info for the comics reader).

Some thoughts...

Thought #1: There's something depressingly crass about this. Not just that Marvel thought it would be a good idea to have Barack Obama appear in a Spider-Man comic—that just seems like smart business. If people will buy the hell out of IDW's plain old Obama-with-no-superheroes comic, or a Savage Dragon comic featuring Obama, imagine the sales of putting the President-Elect in a comic book with a household name superhero! But Jesus, why's it gotta be a variant scheme?

I don't have any insider knowledge on ratios and what not, but if this is a 50/50 variant, then retailers will have to buy a fuckload's worth to all the Obama one's they'll need; that's the cover any civilians rushing in to get this valuable comic book will want, right? (At least there's only one variant I guess; they could have gone really nuts and had a Zombie Obama variant or a Monkey Obama variant...either of those would have certainly gained even more media attention).

The solicitation info's a little wonky, too. The other, non-Obama cover will be by John Romita Sr. (sweet!) and feature Peter Parker with his arms around two ladies while Spidey lurks in the background. There's nothing about Obama, Zeb Wells, Todd Nauck or The Chameleon in it—the only creators listed are Mark Waid, Barry Kitson and Mark Farmer, and the plot points mentioned allude to Peter going on a date and a vague bit about a significant threat gathering.

It also says the book costs $2.99; Diamond's shipping list says it will cost $3.99.



Thought #2: In declaring Barack Obama the "President of Spiderman" (and forgetting the hyphen), Wonkette's Ken Layne notes how awful the art appears: "Jesus fucking christ, could Marvel Comics maybe hire somebody who can maybe draw something vaguely resembling the president-elect, rather than 'random negro dude in a suit who also seems to have neck tumors'?"

If you haven't already, do visit USA Today and check out the art. It is pretty terrible, and I like Todd Nauck. Looking at it more closely, it looks like Nauck, who probably isn't the best choice for a comic featuring Barack Obama, since all his faces look alike, had his pencils computer colored without any inking involved. So if it looks softly-lit, blurry and indistinct, that's probably why. That's pretty unfortunate, considering the extra attention this issue will be getting. I suspect Phil Jimenez, who provided the cover above, would have been a far better choice, given how realistic his art can be (although his art doesn't look so hot up there either).


Thought #3: In his interview with Rogers, ASM editor Steve Wacker said, "In future stories, when you see the president and he's a black male, you'll know who he is. But I don't know that we're doing a Barack Obama Marvel Team-Up book...He's not joining the New Avengers."

Can I ask a serious question here for a second? Why not? Not why not have him join the New Avengers, because that would be stupid: They're all wanted criminals that Obama's agents are trying to kill or capture. But why not have a Barack Obama ongoing set in the Marvel Universe?

Marvel already had him co-narrating half of Secret Invasion #8, one of the biggest, most "important" Marvel comics of late, one which set up the new status quo that is going to be so important to future Marvel stories that it necessitates its own logo and branding ("Dark Reign").

President George W. Bush was in Avengers: The Initative, his Western White House at Crawford being threatened by Hydra terrorists. He got Iron Man, Hank Pym and Reed Richards in his office and asked them to be to capture Captain America and kick off Civil War. He shook Yellowjacket's hand and said, "Heckuva job, Pymmy."

The story that's been dominating the Marvel Universe for the last three year has been all about the passage of a controversial federal law and the men and women who support and oppose it.

While the president has been a mostly off-panel force in these stories, why not go ahead and give him a comic book of his own to focus more intently on this stuff? A Marvel West Wing starring President Barack Obama, Henry Gyrich, Norman Osborn and Tony Stark. Meetings with Doctor Doom, The Black Panther and Namor. Behind the scenes in the war against The Inhumans and The Skrulls. Heated debates about the constitutionality of the SHRA and the 42 prison complex and mutant rights.

Think of the publicity the book would get! Good or bad, it would certainly garner attention.


Thought #4: Why the fuck would the President of the United States of America be seen speaking to and "terrorist fist-jabbing" Spider-Man? I mean, you and I know Spidey's a super-hero, and a decent enough guy under his mask. And anyone who sees Joe Quesada on the news or hears him on the radio or reads an interview with him in USA Today and rushes to their nearest comic shop to buy this sure to be a hot, valuable collectible issue to include in their two comic book collection of the death of Superman issue and the death of Captain America issue know he's a hero, but within the Marvel Universe he's viewed as a dangerous criminal and suspected terrorist.

He's a wanted criminal who is so wanted that the federal government employs mass-murderers to try and catch him; when they do catch him, they will put him into an extra-dimensional internment camp—a sort of superhero Guantanamo Bay—until he agrees to unmask and sign the superhero draft that is the Superhuman Registration Act. Remember that thing? It's the thing that all the Marvel heroes were so passionate about that they went to war over it and beat up and even killed their friends over it, and despite the fact that it was central to the reorganization of the Marvel Universe into a hostile police state, no one ever actually tries to enforce it. Iron Man and Ms. Marvel bump into Spider-Man about once a week, and are all just like, "Oh, I'll let you go with a warning this time, but another twelve or fifteen warnings and you're just going to have to get arrested."

I'm trying to think of the real world equivalent to Spider-Man, but I can't seem to do it, because the Marvel Universe is now so extremely far to the right of the real world. A terrorist probably isn't the right comparison here, even though that's the metaphor Mark Millar was working with in Civil War. Maybe seeing Obama give daps to Spidey in the Marvel Universe would be like seeing him kiss Bernie Madoff on the forehead in the real world? Although Madoff might be too weak an analogy, as his crimes are simply economic, whereas Spidey's are a matter of national security...

At any rate, Obama, who bounced fascist tool Tony "Iron Man" Stark from the job of Guy In Charge of Interring All Super-Heroes Who Won't Play Ball With Uncle Sam for not fascist or tool-like enough and replaced him with mass-murdering psychopath Norman "The Green Goblin" Osborn, wouldn't be all that likely to give Spidey daps in the Marvel Universe.

Oh Marvel, why do you keep trying to sell us all these terrible comic book stories all about politics if you yourselves don't even like to adhere to the depressing status quo you spend years arriving at?


Thought #5: Spidey, dude, how did you confuse Adrian "The Vulture" Toomes with Vice President-Elect Joe "Sam The Eagle" Biden? The former is as bald as his namesake, while the latter has snowy white hairplugs?

Wednesday, January 07, 2009

Weekly Haul: January 7th

Black Lightning: Year One #1 (DC Comics) If any of DC’s super-comics were to be held sacrosanct, Black Lightning wasn’t likely to be one of them.

There is no story from any creator that is seen as so influential and so special that DC will leave it alone forever. They’ll leave Barry Allen or Jason Todd dead, but only for a few decades; Mary Marvel can be a slutty, murderous Suicide Girl wannabe; a Justice League villain can rape a Justice Leaguer’s wife on the meeting table while Superman cries about it on the cover; Neil Gaiman’s Sandman can end when the writer wants it too, but spin-offs will continue indefinitely.

So it would obviously be pretty naïve to expect the short-lived, eleven-issue, 1977 Black Lightning series by Tony Isabella and Trevor Von Eeden to receive any kind of special protection from being messed with by other writers.

Still, it’s always somewhat frustrating when other editors, writers and artists start overwriting past stories, in large part because it compromises the contract between DCU comics readers and makers—that we treat the characters as if they are more or less real people with real lives that progress logically and chronologically. Examples? Well, when Judd Winick introduced Anissa “Thunder” Pierce, 22-year-old daughter of Jefferson “Black Lightning” Pierce, who had never previously had a daughter. Or when Geoff Johns later introduced Black Lightning’s never-before-mentioned wife and second daughter.

Like I said, Black Lightning the book and Black Lightning the character (who outlived his first series, appearing in Batman and The Outsiders and a second, slightly longer-lived 1990’s solo book), don’t really have any special retcon immunity, and yet sometimes it feels like they should, if only because of the character’s status as the first black superhero from the comics publisher that originated the concept of the superhero. Black Lightning is basically the Jackie Robinson of the DCU, and as poor as the stories featuring him may be relative to the rest of DC’s output in the years since, there’s still something kind of special about them (even if not special enough to exempt them from being made irrelevant).

None of this is to say that there’s necessarily anything wrong with DC re-telling Black Lightning’s origin story; if anything, the out-of-left field changes Winick and Johns introduced all but necessitate one. There are other problems with the character, which I kind of sort of addressed in this 2007 post that I don’t really want to get into again here, beyond noting that the character is very much a product of his times (note the name), and yet because the DCU operates on a sort of sliding timeline, where the heroes never age more than a few years, and Black Lightning has thus never been Black Lightning more than ten years or so into the past, a product of the ‘70s in our world is now a product of the ‘90s in his world.

So rebooting Black Lightning and rewriting his story? A necessary evil at this point, thanks both to moves made by a couple of writers and the nature of DCU comics. I don’t begrudge DC doing this series, nor writer Jen Van Meter for writing it, although I do wish she would have taken the opportunity to “fix” his codename (by making the color of the lightning he shoots either black-black, or black light black—that is, purplish) and that she adhered a bit closer to the character’s first year as it was originally presented.

This is only the first sixth of the story, of course, so maybe what seem like drastic changes now will seem less so as the rest of it unfolds, but one significant change—beyond giving Pierce a wife and a little girl named Anissa—is that his powers now seem to be natural, something he was born with. In his original series, he wore a special belt that gave him his lightning powers (making him more of a Batman, Steel or Mister Terrific type character who was a self-made, inherently bad-ass hero augmenting his crime-fighting with a super tool, rather than a Superman, Flash or Wonder Woman-like superhuman character). It wasn’t until later that his “latent meta-gene” activated and he internalized his powers. (It could be that Van Meter just hasn’t gotten to fully explaining all this yet; she’s already introduced the man who helped him invent the belt, so maybe it will turn out that he still uses it to regulate and focus an inherent power).

Is this way too nerdy for you? Sorry; I just find Black Lightning pretty fascinating, as he embodies so many of the problems of a shared setting “universe” like the DCU (or Marvel Universe) that I (obviously) find so interesting.

Enough background I guess, how’s the actual comic book?

Pretty darn good, actually. It’s a surprisingly full comic book, it took me about three times as long to read as any other super-comic in my stack this week, in large part due to the simple fact that the pages were relatively panel-packed (eight-panel pages are not uncommon here). It’s not super-dense or anything though. Van Meter has Jeff’s wife narrate, and her familiar with his history without actually having been present for all of it point-of-view makes her a perfect character to tell readers about him; she’s essentially introducing us to her husband.

Van Meter has taken a lot of what was in the original version of the story—Suicide Slum, The 100, Tobias Whale, tailor Peter Gambi—and added in the characters that Winick and Johns would later retcon into Black Lightning’s life.

There’s a somewhat unnecessary three-page action scene at the beginning, and then we flash back a bit to Jefferson Pierce moving his family back to Suicide Slum to work at a school and, hopefully, reclaim his neighborhood from the unusual level of gang violence. Van Meter introduces a lot of characters here, and gets quite a lot done in the issue. It reminded me a little bit of a superhero Lean on Me, if Morgan Freeman vaulted fences and delivered flying kicks to thugs’ faces in that movie.

I mean that in a good way, by the way.

The art is by Cully Hamner, and while he’s not an artist I would have thought of as perfect for the book—Von Eeden or Eddy Newell springing most immediately to mind; I bet Damion Scott would have been an interesting choice, given how Van Meter introduces the character and Scott’s use of graffiti-influenced graphics in the past—he does a hell of a job here. The art is, simply put, perfect; there’s not a damn thing wrong with it.

Sadly, there was no answer to the question I’m most curious about—will Black Lightning still wear a special afro wig attached to his mask to disguise his true identity? I guess I’ll have to keep reading to find out. I won’t mind; this was a surprisingly good read.


Blue Monday: Thieves Like Us #1 (Oni Press)It seems like forever since I’ve seen my fake friends from Jefferson High School, so its great to have Chynna Clugston back for another go round of teenage dramedy (In fact, it’s been so long that I think the last time I read a Blue Monday mini, I was able to download all of Clugston’s suggested soundtrack tracks from Napster or a Napster-like file-sharing thingee).

This apparently picks up where Clugston left off long ago, and yet the few minor romantic developments in Bleu’s circle of friends were all so minor that nothing seems to have changed at all (One could probably start with this issue having never read any previous Blue Monday comics before).

At Bleu’s instigation, they spend the day at the zoo, where our heroine is dismayed to find that every animal she looks at seems to start having sex (Victor blames it on her “super-pheromones or something”). Sex is actually on her mind a lot, and, by book’s end, she decides she needs to lose her virginity before she can finally land the object of her crush, teacher Mr. Bishop.

Hilarity, and some touching shojo-like moments of romantic drama, will likely ensue.


El Diablo #5 (DC) I haven’t read another issue of this six-part miniseries by Jai Nitz, Phil Hester and Ande Parks since the first one, which I didn’t hate, but didn’t like enough to follow it above the gazillion other superhero comics choice available (Looking back at what I said after the first issue last September, I thought the Hester/Parks team was as sharp as always, and that “writer Jai Nitz… does a perfectly adequate crime story in this first issue, and if the direction isn’t terribly original…Nitz doesn’t do anything wrong here either.”)

I decided to check back in with the series this week simply because it was a very, very light of new releases that I was at all interested in, and this issue featured The Freedom Fighters, characters I kind of like, even if I couldn’t make it through this new incarnation’s first miniseries.

Anyway, there are worse uses of $2.99 than 22-pages of Hester and Parks drawing Uncle Sam and his friends fighting some funny-looking dudes.

This being mostly just a big fight issue, it wasn’t really that hard to follow. El Diablo III or IV (I lost count) is sick of his job of avenging the dead that The Spectre, Ragman and Crimson Avenger II don’t avenge, and asks some guy in a terrible costume with the terrible codename of Vorpal who has a sword for an arm to cut off his head. Then The Freedom Fighters show up and kick the shit out of them for a while, until El Diablo starts kicking the shit out of them, and then we cut away to a two-panel flashback to El Diablo’s trial, and then we cut away to two panels of a sexy devil lady pouring a goblet of blood in the eye of a devil guy and announcing her pregnancy. The end.

I’m going to go ahead and call this a disappointment, but only because Uncle Sam fails to say “consarn” at any point, and I like when he says that.

I should also note that the lettering is really great. Lettering is one of those things that I never really notice unless it’s really great or really bad, so I just wanted to point out that Sal Cipriano’s lettering is really great…it looks hand-written, which gives the book a nice, comic book-y feel that is too often lost today in this era of kids with their computers and their loud music and their rollerblades and their baggy pants.


Essential Man-Thing Vol. 2 (Marvel Comics) I haven’t read a single word of this yet, aside from the table of contents to check its Gerbericity and Ploogosity, but I did buy it at the shop today, so on the list it goes. I guess I can at least judge it by its cover, and note that they’ve apparently changed the design of the Essentials, which makes me sad. Now the spine of Vol. 2 won’t match the spine of Vol. 1, and this will cause me some level of psychic distress for the rest of my life.



Secret Six #5 (DC) So, I guess this “Faces of Evil” thing is more a design cover scheme than anything else, then? This issue bears a “Faces of Evil” logo along the bottom, and has the name “Deadshot” stamped in white in the same font over the dimmed logo, with the cover bearing a portrait-esque image of Deadshot over a black field.

The contents are simply part five of writer Gail Simone and artists Nicola Scot and Doug Hazlewood’s ongoing story arc. In the past when DC did these sorts of cover schemes— the post-Zero Hour #0 issues, “Big Head” Month, Eisner-esque logo month—the stories tended to be either done-in-ones or the beginnings of new arcs, perfect jumping on point type stories for readers attracted by the marketing scheme.

Not that that’s a bad thing of course; Secret Six is one of DC’s most consistent books at the moment, and probably the best team book they’ve got going. It just seems like a bit of a lost opportunity is all.

This chapter seems to the penultimate one of the current story arc, in which the extremely creepy villain Junior has hired a bunch of random super-villains to steal one of the more imaginative maguffins in modern super-comics from our titular team. It ends with the (quite surprising) surprise identity of Junior, as he disrobes to confront The Six. What precedes it is Junior and his man torturing a narrating Bane—by tying him up and throwing bricks at him—and Deadshot narrating as he and his teammates recover from being poisoned last issue.

I know I spend/waste a lot of verbiage decrying how dark, dreary and inappropriately violent and ghoulish super-comics are today, especially DC’s super-comics, but what seems horribly out of place in Green Lantern or Teen Titans works quite well in a book like this which is, after all, a book about nasty villains who fight nastier villains. It also helps that Simone is a really good writer who can sell such nastiness in a way that makes it seem integral to the story rather than exploitive SHOCK!! tactics, and that Nicola Scott can draw human beings.

Quick question to anyone with a better memory than me: Can King Shark talk when he’s out of water? I thought he explained in Sword of Aquaman that he couldn’t, which is why he was just a berserk monster in all his Superboy appearances. According to Wikipedia, he has spoken in other stories, but Jeph Loeb wrote those, so I think that means they occurred on Earth-WTF? Just curious. He talks an awful lot in this issue.



Spider-Man: Fear Itself #1 (Marvel) Hey Marvel, what’s up? I have a question for you, if you don’t mind. What exactly is up with your pricing these days? Because, looking at some of your releases lately, it seems like you’re still trying to figure out what you should put in a $3.99 comic book. Your Max, Marvel Knights and most of your miniseries are $3.99 for 22 story pages, and a cardstock cover. That seems pretty outrageous, and is too rich for my blood.

But then in a book like this week’s Punisher #1, the one in which Punny fights The Sentry, you charge $3.99 for just 22 story pages, but you throw in a bunch of bonus material, which, if my memory of my two-second flip-through is correct, was some kind of history of The Punisher. Nothing anybody needs to read or anything—he’s a guy who fights crime by shooting criminals to death, the end—but I guess something for that extra $1 is better than nothing.

But this $3.99 book is a 34 story pages long. And Wolverine: Switchback, which also came out this week, is 32 story pages long.

So what gives exactly? Are you guys still experimenting, or what? If so, I’m not sure if this is the best way to do it, as other factors will determine which format sells the most (that is, Secret Invasion is going to outsell a Namor miniseries, a Wolverine one-shot and a Spider-Man/Man-Thing one-shot by the virtue of being a big crossover story, regardless of price point). If you’re taking a vote, I’ll pay $3.99 for a 32-to-34 page comic.

Anyway, this is an odd little one-off branded as an Amazing Spider-Man story* and set in the main book’s continuity, but relegated out of the almost-weekly series because…well, I don’t know why, exactly. Perhaps because there’s a four-month jump between two scenes of this book that wouldn’t quite gel with the almost-weekly soap opera format.

It’s written by Stuart Moore and features gorgeous art by Joe Suitor which you really oughta check out (it’s much better than the cover art, by Mico Suayan and Frank D’Armata.

Suitor’s Man-Thing is massive…just gigantic, and rather than the made-of-muck version I’ve been reading about in Essential Man-Thing, he’s more Swamp Thing-y in that he’s made out of plants. He’s got mushrooms growing out his head, bits of large, barky trees growing out of him, and even some thorns for skin-piercing..

His Spider-Man is very yong and youthful looking, with a bulbous head atop a skinny but somewhat athletic body. The only other super-character he draws is a glimpse or two of The Lizard, and this wonderful image of Spidey turning into a Lizard that appears in Spidey’s eye at one point .

As for the story, it opens with a cute young Peter Parker wearing super-thick glasses and water wings clutching a huge bug jar while asking Aunt May about fear, then flashforwards to a fight between Spidey and Manny in the Everglades, and then jumps four months ahead again, when Peter is in New York City, and being stalked by Man-Thing.

Moore’s script somewhat ambitiously (or, put negatively, pretentiously) addresses the nature of fear, and the various ways Peter Parker processes it and he does so successfully, although its hard to imagine anyone who reads a Spider-Man/Man-Thing crossover much caring about the psychological life of Peter Parker. There’s a bit at the climax that I really loved, in part because of just how melodramatic it was: The Man-Thing experiences fear and since whatever knows fear burns at the Man-Thing’s touch, he explodes into flame.


Trinity #32 (DC) The front, Busiek and Bagley story is set on Egg World, and it is just hilarious this week. It starts with the Egg Worldian Bat-god holding his bird creature dressed like Robin and named “Rabat” all A Death In The Family trade cover style and screaming “RABAAAAAAT!” at the heavens, then the Claymation-looking aliens call each other by their hilarious full names (“They are visitors from a far place, Shevri Bird-Herder**,” “Out of respect for you, Korsan Net-Wielder,” and like that), and it climaxes with them accusing She-Lane Lo-Is and her friends of being "Machinists! MACHINISTS AMONG US!"

The back-up, this time drawn by Mike Norton and Ande Parks, is mostly a quieter scene involving Tomorrow Woman and Triumph heroically fighting to restore the “real” DCU, even though they secretly know it will cost them both their own lives. Pretty old-school superhero pathos, but well done.



Wolverine: Switchback (Marvel) I’m glad I decided to flip through this Wolverine one-shot this week (again, it was a light week), as I otherwise would have missed it completely, thinking I’ve already read all the Wolverine stories I need to read.

Marvel didn’t exactly do anything to help sell the damn thing. The original solicitation, which is still up on their website, only mentions the title story by writer Joseph Clark and artist Das Pastoras. There’s actually an eight-page back-up written by Gregg Hurwitz and artist (and EDILW favorite) Juan Doe.

I ended up buying it for the Doe art, but the lead story was the one I enjoyed the most.

That’s essentially just another riff on the Wolverine goes on a trip somewhere and ends up killing someone who needs killing story (You know, for a guy on, like, seven superhero teams, he sure seems to take a lot of vacations), although Clark does a pretty good job executing it, always erring on the side of underplaying and understating things, building up the anticipation for the expected claw-popping and dude-killing. There’s really no suspense in this sort of story, so the writer’s real challenge is to make the trip to the foregone conclusion an interesting one.

Driving by a mountain road, Wolvie smells a suspicious area where a lot of folks have apparently died horribly in car crashes, and he stops in nearby Pottsville to investigate. The clues point toward the sheriff, and Wolverine drives into the trap to get the proof he needs and get close enough to kill the bad guy.

Pastoras’ art is pretty sensational, much more than the rather ugly cover image of Wolverine in his silly gimp-suit would indicate. The art looks painted, and may very well be painted, the sets and backgrounds looking somewhat photorealistic without being photo dependent. The character designs are fantastic, and Pastoras’ Wolverine is actually a really beautiful characters. Despite the sever widow’s peak, the Ogami Ito eyebrows and sideburns than give way into some kinda Wolfman hair helmet, he has striking blue eyes, smooth skin and sharp features. There’s something puckish, even Peter Pan-ish about Pastoras’ Wolverine; he looks “right” (small, hairy, etc.), but, drawn like this, it’s not as hard as usual to wonder why so many beautiful women are always trying to sleep with him.

His villain is similarly well designed. A big, doughy, swollen man stuffed into a brown uniform, a man so pale he seems to emit light from his moon-sized face.

I’m always shocked when I read a really, really good Wolverine story, which happens just enough that I shouldn’t really be shocked any more, yet it’s always nice to find one, and be reminded of why exactly this character is so popular in the first place.

(I do always find it amusing when the characters in these Logan’s-just-passing-through type stories never seem to know who Wolverine is. Are there that many four-foot-tall bad asses with Wolfman hair in the Marvel Universe? Does Wolvie not show up on film somehow, and that’s why civilians don’t seem to recognize the Avenger and X-Man who must be on the news on a nightly basis?)

The back-up, the reason I bought the book, was incredibly stupid, although Doe’s art, colored all in red and brown with splashes of a creamy, almost yellow off-white, is pleasant to look at, more highly abstracted than usual.

The story, scripted by Gregg Hurwitz, is entitle “Punching Bag” and it starts out just fine. Wolverine’s had a long day, and wants a drink, but he keeps finding trouble. When a carload of rapists/murderers abduct a woman and take her to a cave, he pops his claws and runs at them. One of them punches him so hard that he flies up to the ceiling of the cave, his claws above his head, and they bury themselves in the roof of the cave and stick so tightly he can’t retract them, leaving them hanging there like a punching bag.

Even forgiving the likelihood of a 300-pound guy like Wolverine (that metal skeleton’s heavy, remember) getting punched Popeye style to the top of a cave so hard that his long-ass claws are driven into the stone like nails into wood, there’s really no reason he couldn’t just cut his way our by pushing ‘em forward through the stone (admantium, cuts through anything, etc.), or pull himself up and use his feet to push his claws out of the stone (have you seen the abs on that guy? Surely he can do a pull-up)

Instead, he decides to taunt the rapists into punching him over and over until they eventually hit him so hard they break him free. This means Wolverine telling a “Your Momma’s so ugly” and a “Your Momma’s so fat” joke.

It made me sad to read, and a little embarrassed for Hurwitz.

Probably the most interesting part of the story is the t shirt one of the thugs is wearing. There’s a white circle in the middle of his shirt with what looks like a red swastika in it, but one of the “arms” has been removed, so it’s actually three-fourths of a swastika. But it’s centered in the circle as if it was originally a full swastika, and the fourth arm was digitally removed somehow (I’ll try and post some scans of it at some point [UPDATE: I did. Here). I guess Marvel decided to have Doe alter it so as not to have a swastika in the art? I’m exactly sure why; the book doesn’t have a Marvel rating on it, but does say “Parental Advisory,” and, hell, aren’t there like 50 swastikas per issue of Captain America…?



*Well, the cover says “the Amazing Spider-Man” in ASM’s logo font, but the fine print refers to it as Spider-Man: Fear Itself.

**Wait, large groups of birds aren’t called “herds,” they’re called “flocks.” Why doesn’t that guy go by Shevri Bird-Flocker, as if I didn’t know?

Tuesday, January 06, 2009

Are the funnies still more saddening than funny...?

Over the summer, a copy of the funnies page from Bradenton, Florida’s Bradenton Herald found its way into my apartment via visiting relatives, and I took the opportunity to check in on the funnies after a few years’ absence from what used to be a daily ritual.

In November, I found a day-old copy of the Columbus Dispatch, Ohio’s worst newspaper, in the break room of my day job, and thought I’d see how their funnies pages looked these days.

Here’s how their funnies pages physically look:



They’re actually a funny-page-and-a-half, with the half of the first page devoted to a pair of crossword puzzles and a couple of other puzzle-y things—a jumble, a word search, and something called a “challenger” and the “daily cryptoquotes.”

There are 31 strips altogether, five one-panel cartoons, and the rest actual strip-strips.

Here’s what they have on their funny-page-and-a-half these days…


Peanuts

The Dispatch is one of the many, many papers that is rerunning old Peanuts strips. I like the strip as much as the next guy—actually, I probably like it a lot more than the next guy, depending on who I’m standing next to at any given time—but I don’t really like the idea of running old strips in the paper like this forever. There’s no greater sign of the imminent death of the newspaper comic strip than the fact that decades-old work from dead cartoonists continues to be judged more relevant and vibrant than anything living cartoonists are creating today (at least by newspaper editors and readers).

This is a strip about how Pig-Pen is really dirty.


B.C.

Here’s another strip from a creator who’s died. Rather than running old strips by creator Johnny Hart, however, B.C. has become a legacy strip. It’s currently drawn by Mason Mastroianni, Hart’s grandson.

He seems to be doing an adequate job of filling in for his late grandfather, as only his signature in the lower right corner of the last panel tipped me off that this wasn’t a repeat. It’s a three-panel strip set in the ant “skool,” in which the little student ant says he fails to see the resemblance between George Washington and the Washington Monument.

It wasn’t very funny.


Hagar The Horrible

Oddly, the last time I took a look at a funnies page like this, the Hagar strip was a joke about the title character struggling with his diet (You know, a typical Viking concern). And in this strip, he’s also struggling with his diet!

“How’s your diet going, Hagar?” asks Lucky Eddie, and Helga answers from off panel, “It just went…”

She finishes her statement in the next panel, which shows a pleased Hagar tucking in to a huge turkey leg, spittle flying in all directions. He’s sitting alone at a table, while a sad looking Helga stands above what looks like a huge bowl of steaming potatoes at the end of the table.

Why is she so sad looking? Is it because she’s apparently prepared Hagar’s feast for him—she’s wearing an apron and has a wooden spoon in her hand—and thus facilitated her husband’s destructive lifestyle?

I don’t know, but it is certainly a pretty sad thought for the funnies page.

The last time I read the funnies, Hagar was one of the few highlights, but this time the gag is no more amusing than, say, your average Hi & Lois. Speaking of which…


Hi & Lois

Ditto is on a chair in front of the cookie jar, eating a chocolate sandwich cookie of the Oreo-like type. Hi sister scolds him, telling him that mom said he can’t have any until after dinner.

“I’ll deal with that later.”

In the second and final panel, Dot tells on him: “Ditto is running up a cookie deficit!” Lois, in the foreground in the act of cooking dinner, has a shocked expression, her eyes wide like saucers, her cheeks flushed, and motion lines off to the side of her head indicating some kind of wobbling.

She looks as if Dot had just said, “Mom, what’s ‘a product of incest’ mean?” rather than just hearing her daughter apply some random phrase she heard on the news to cookies.

The strip bears Chance Browne’s signature, but the Dispatch credits Brian Walker, Greg Walker and Chance Browne. Do they all work on every strip (surely three people didn’t come up with this one lame strip, did they?), or do they take turns? Or perhaps they all have their names in the credits as part of a deal to share the blame for these things…?


Marvin

This is a three-panel, mostly silent strip, if you don’t count the “Z” in the bubble above Marvin’s head, and his “WAH!” in panel two.

So here’s the joke: In panel one, he’s sleepwalking into his dad’s room. In panel two, he cries, and his dad wakes up, with a “!” in a bubble above his head. In panel three, the father is changing Marvin’s diaper, and he’s sleeping again.

Ha ha ha! Babies cry when they need changed, and they often need changed in the middle of the night! Right when you’d like to be asleep, not changing diapers! It’s funny, because it’s true.

Wait, it’s not funny at all. But it is true. Not a joke, just a statement of fact. Like, a drawing of a statement of fact. These could just be cartoonier-than-usual illustrations in a chapter in a parenting book.


Pearls Before Swine

This strip, by Stephan Pastis, is new to the Dispatch. Or at least relatively new. It wasn’t there the last time I read the paper. Which, admittedly, was at least three years ago. I’ve never read it before, although I did recently read a New York Times article about the creator.

This particular strip is captioned “Rat As Corporate Counsel,” and features three panels of a guy in a suit and tie asking a rat in a tie at a desk for some legal advice about something. It reads exactly like a Dilbert strip, although Pastis’ art is more detailed and fluid.


Zits

I like Jim Borgman’s art in general, although this is a less than bravura strip by him, and the gag is more verbal than visual. Jeremy has a big project due tomorrow and he hasn’t even started yet. That’s…that’s the whole joke really. His mom is upside down clinging to a wall like Spider-Man in the last panel, and the dad appears to say “The boy driving you up the wall again, honey?”

I guess it’s kind of amusing that the father calls his son “the boy,” and Jerry Scott and Borgman do have Jeremy add more fuel to the fire by asking, “By the way, do we have any poster board?”

But like Marvin, this basically amounts to a simple dry observation about the behavior of kids. With a lame-ass visual pun tacked on.


Stone Soup

Here’s a strip I’m not very familiar with, and I don’t much see any reason to familiarize myself with it.

There are four panels, each featuring two little girls drawn from the shins up in a background-less white void. The smaller of the two girls is chocking, the older one panics for a few panels and then gives her the Heimlich, successfully ejecting whatever was obstructing her throat.

And that’s the whole strip. By this example, I’m not sure if this is supposed to be a funny strip or a dramatic one; it’s drawn in a funny strip style, but there isn’t really anything funny about this particular installment.


Dilbert

Calling attention to how Dilbert-like the above installment of Pearls was, this one is also three panels, and is laid out with Dilbert at a desk in profile, staring at the exact same type of computer as Rat was in the above strip.

Dilbert thinks to himself that he wants to be productive, but the Internet is calling to him. And it does, out loud: “Hey, buddy. I’ve got pictures of gadgets.”

Dilbert’s ready to get sucked in, and the Internet knows Dilbert is its bitch. Another rather sad statement on human weakness and addiction along the lines of Hagar, but Adams gets points for making the Internet somewhat sarcastic and cruel. (“Cool ones?” Dilbert asks at the mention of gadgets, and the Internet responds, “Sure, let’s pretend that matters.”)

This is the funniest strip of the lot so far.


Tina’s Groove

Here’s another short, two-panel strip, formatted as your standard set-up, punchline joke.

In the first panel, Tina is at the head of a line before two others, and says, “It looks like the economic meltdown is about to hurt us regular folks” with no punctuation of any kind at the end of her sentence. (Wait, “about?” And hey, Tina, last I knew, was a waitress at a diner. Hasn’t she always been hurting economically?).

“...This is the first time I’ve seen the teller’s panic button on the other side of the counter…” she says in the last panel, and we see a little button marked “emergency.”

So I guess if a customer feels the bank is robbing them, they can call the police to…do…something…?

This comic strip is by a cartoonist named Rina Piccolo. That is an awesome name. It is, in fact, the best name on the entire one and a half pages of funnies, of either creators or characters.

Just below this strip, which is at the bottom of the page, is big, bold font reading “JUDGE PARKER and CATHY can be found on Page F4 in the Dispatch classifieds.” So I guess they didn’t drop those strips, they just shoved them back into the classifieds, where only the unemployed and/or the most dedicated Judge Parker and Cathy fans will find them.


Ziggy

Okay, this is the funniest thing on the funny pages:



Ha ha ha! When did the seventh and final Harry Potter come out, exactly? Was it July of 2007? So, almost a year and a half before this cartoon ran? And look, here’s good old Ziggy, noticing that there seems to be a lot of money in the Harry Potter books.


Six Chix

This installment of the one-panel cartoon shared by six female cartoonists. In this one, by Anne Gibbons, there are two naked ladies holding barrels around them to cover their shame, and the first one says to the other one, “I guess sleeping through history class wasn’t such a great idea.”

See, these are college girls, and they apparently fell asleep during history class, so their classmates stole all of their clothes. But, because their classmates aren’t completely heartless, they left them two barrels with which to cover themselves.


Family Circus

This one is over my head, as I don’t know anything about music. Something about quarter notes only costing 25-cents.


Marmaduke

“The obedience school will give Marmaduke an honorary degree if he wont’ attend any more classes.”

Is Marmaduke in repeats now? Because I could swear I’ve seen that gag a few dozen times before. Maybe it’s just because there’s only like two different Marmaduke jokes, one involving digging holes and the other how disobedient he is…?


Moderately Confused

This one’s new to me too, and if I never read another one that’s totally fine with me. There’s a painter painting a still life, and a woman comes up behind him and says “Nice detail on the product placement,” despite the fact that there doesn’t seem to be any product in the ordinary bowl of fruit he’s painting. Maybe there’s a bottle of Coke off-panel or something?


Blondie

A lame three-panel gag, noteworthy only for the last panel:




Frank & Ernest

The title characters are taxi drivers, and the big one—is that Frank?— says to the smaller one, “Everybody I drive to the airport seems to lose their fear of flying.” His taxi is all beat up, as if he were in many accidents. See, he’s such a bad driver that after riding with him, flying in a plane doesn’t seem so scary.


Funky Winkerbean

It’s been a while since I’ve read this strip; has there been another generational jump into the future? Because the coach character looks about 20 years older than the last time I saw him.

Anyway, this particular strip has nothing to do with cancer. It’s a one-panel strip, and in it the now-elderly looking coach is addressing six young women wearing basketball gear, all of whom have remarkably realistically drawn faces, and stutters, “Okay, listen up, girls…er, women…er…”

And then one of the girls says, “Ladies,” and the coach says, “Thank you!”

I like Batiuk’s lettering.


Sherman’s Lagoon

It’s always bugged me that the turtle character, Fillmore, doesn’t appear to be a sea turtle, but can breathe and talk underwater. Even though, whatever kind of turtle he is, he’d still need to breathe air. I’m not sure about the crab. It’s been a long time since freshman biology. In any case, while Jim Toomey’s a great character designer and pretty good artist, I can never get past the fact that his characters all seem amphibious to just enjoy the strip. (This particular one is even more complicated, as it involves a radio station, that broadcasts underwater…? To a radio on the surface? And there’s a telephone involved?


Garfield

This wasn’t as lame as I expected, as it deals with the Liz/Jon romance. He still seems loser-ish, and Garfield is still excited about food, but this was a remarkably character-based strip.


Sally Forth

Sally bakes croissants while some lady in an ugly vest and hoop earrings pours herself a glass of wine she drains in the time it takes Sally to ask “What?” They talk about men. There’s a joke in there somewhere, but I didn’t really get it.


One Big Happy

I’d prefer not to talk about this strip, I dislike it so.


Agnes

I actually hate this strip. When I used to have a subscription to the Dispatch, back when I was young and foolish and had just moved to Columbus and was looking in its classifieds every day for a job, I used to read every strip except Agnes, I hate it so much.


For Better Or For Worse

Hey look, the Patterson children, who have somehow magically reverted to childhood, have just got a new puppy.

Aw, look at what a cute little puppy he is...



And it will be really sad when he does, too.



Overboard

This is Chip Dunham’s strip that takes place on a boat of some kind. Maybe a pirate shipt? It’s been a really long time since I’ve read it. In this strip, a four-panel one, two guys try to break in to the safe of the protagonists, while mice use Morse code to foil the robbery.

Some of these are sometimes pretty amusing, but I’ve never been able to develop any affection for Dunham’s art, with is rather minimal.


Beetle Bailey

A two-panel strip by Mort, Greg and Brian Walker finds Sarge yelling at a reclining Beetle, “I told you to cut the grass!” And Beetle repiles, “It doesn’t do any good to cut it, it keeps growing back. The Asian dude appears in the second panel to ask Sarge, “You’re not going to clobber him?” and Sarge replies, “It doesn’t do any good. He just keeps goofing off.”

It’s funny (?) because he says what Beetle says.


The Middletons

This two-panel strip features two of the characters in close-up in the first panel, talking about how nice the weather is for running, and the second panel zooms out to reveal they’re actually sitting in lawn chairs, while their dogs run around chasing each other.


Baby Blues

The older sister makes fun of the younger brother for still using a pacifier. It’s not funny. Like, at all.


Jump Start

The little boy in school who plays doctor all the time—I think his name is actually Doctor Appleby—has another little boy up on a counter and has his knee-hitting hammer cocked, saying “I’m going to whack you in the knee with a rubber hammer.”

The boy playing patient protests, noting that he’s got a broken nose, so Doctor Appleby doesn’t need to check his reflexes.

In the last panel, Appleby regards the hammer with a blank-eyed stare, and thinks to himself, “This thing tests reflexes? Learn somethin’ new every day!”

I thought that was kind of funny.


Doonesbury

Individual Doonesbury strips tend to be less funny than a run of them taken as a whole. I haven’t been reading it for quite some time now, and now that I think of it, I wonder if I was really missing out all year, as this was a pretty exciting year in American politics (obviously). In this one, the title character’s daughter interviews her grandmother on her cell phone. There’s some gentle character humor in here that’s competently done, if not exactly the sort of joke that would make one guffaw. As part of a larger, longer scene, it will probably read just fine.


Get Fuzzy

Darby Conley’s character designs really kind of freak me out. The dog and cat characters in this strip are just so ugly-looking. They’re well-drawn, I just kind of hate the way they look. The writing is pretty sharp though. This particular installment is pretty funny, if I’m reading it correctly (and I may not be, as it seems to be part of a story arc involving the cat founding his own country within the house he shares with his master and fellow pet, the bland-eyed, pot belly-dragging dog goblin.

Monday, January 05, 2009

Bob Staake draws very well

I have something of a bad habit of devoting a day’s posting to a subject other than comics, which is probably less than ideal given that this is a comics blog. Of course, I think children’s picture books overlap j-u-u-u-s-t enough with comics that it’s still well worth taking a look at some of them, even when they’re not the work of comics creators or presented in a comic book-like format.

So I won’t be making a New Year’s resolution to quit posting about the occasional children’s book here.

Tonight I wanted to talk a little bit about the work of Bob Staake, whom I had assumed was just an extremely talented children’s book illustrator, but, a quick poke around his website reveals, is a prolific illustrator whose clients include just about everyone who ever hires illustrators for anything (From The New Yorker on down).

It doesn’t take much looking to see what’s so exciting about Staake’s art. He constructs images out of a few big shapes, seamlessly fused together to both disguise themselves as components and emphasize their own simplicity. His colors are bold and bright, and he gives everything a jaunty, highly animated angle that makes each and every picture pop.

If it sounds like I’m gushing, I do have something negative to say: Staake’s not much of a poet, although he constructs the children’s books of his that I’ve read in rhyme.

The Donut Chef (Golden Books; 2008) is the first book of Staake’s I noticed, the combination of one of my favorite subjects (doughnuts) and the striking cover image, with all of those repeating circles, attracting me.

It’s the story of a big, round doughnut chef who comes to town and opens an extremely successful doughnut shop called Donut Land. A surprisingly evil looking (for a baker) baker lurks around for a few pages, before announcing his intention to open his own doughnut shop—right next door!

The two compete fiercely, offering various discounts and incentives and, eventually, experimenting with ever wilder flavors and shapes, until they get so far away from the initial concept of a doughnut that it’s a stretch to even call their doughnuts doughnuts anymore.



It all works out in the end, when a little girl asks for a plain glazed doughnut, reminding the big round chef of what doughnuts are all about.

I’m not sure I agree with the moral—that glazed are best*—but the artwork sure is agreeable.

Stake’s doughnuts all look good enough to eat, and he lavishes plenty of attention on the city streets, with its many passersby and cars, it’s slightly tilted, brightly colored buildings and the rainbow of soft, bright colors that make them up. It’s been a long, long time since I’ve read a picture book in which everything looked so nice that I kinda wished I could somehow step inside it myself.

(For more on The Donut Chef, including sample pages and a YouTube presentation, click here).

From there I worked backwards through the two others my local library had.


Next up was The Red Lemon (Golden Books; 2006), the story of a rotund lemon farmer by the name of Farmer McPhee, who looks an awful lot like the rotund doughnut baker.

The construction of Staake’s sentences can be a little awkward as he stretches for rhymes, the words chosen not for how natural they wound or how well they flow, but simply because of the sounds they make:

There’s nothing like lemons.
This fruit isn’t mellow.
They’re tangy!
They’re tasty!
They’re tart—
and soooooo
yellow!


And like that.



After we spend a few pages learning about how much Farmer McPhee loves lemons and his usual process of getting them from tree to store, the titular fruit raises its rind.

As McPhee is carrying an overflowing crate of Mcphee Farms 100% Yellow Perfection Lemons, he notices a red lemon on an otherwise yellow tree.

Staake’s use of color in this book is pretty great. The lettering of the word “yellow” and “red” is sometimes colored yellow and red, and in the scene where McPhee picks the red lemon and stares at it in angry contemplation, the bright yellow, blues and greens of the book so far disappear, and we get a beautiful two-page spread in which everything—the sky, the clouds, the ground, the trees, the fruit, McPhee—are all red, with only the whites of the farmer’s eyes and the font that the next few lines of rhymes are in standing out as white.

McPhee winds up and hurls the red lemon out to an island over the sea, and then two hundred years pass. In that time, the red lemon that hit the island has turned into a small red lemon orchard, and a vibrant community has grown on the island, based all around the red lemon industry, which is apparently quite a delicacy.

It just goes to show that…um…Hm. I’m not sure what the lesson is here. It’s okay to be different, because within 200 years you’ll be accepted?

Anyway, the art’s great. Here’s half of a spread devoted to showing us around the island a bit:


Staake’s art is packed with little details (check out the brand name on the island clock), and I really liked this one, although I don’t really understand it:


“Better Red Than Wed?” What the hell’s that mean? Better a communist than married? Red Lemons are even better than a life partner?

And the final Staake book for the evening is the one with a title even more exciting than The Donut Chef, Hello, Robots! (Viking; 2004).

This is the story of four robots who seem to all live in the same house and, according to the narration, apparently serve the narrator and the narrator’s family/roommates, although no humans are ever seen.

These robots are Blink, “the one who cooks our meals” (and resembles a red, robot version of the donut chef); Zinc, a purple handy-robot who “an fix things made of steel;” Blip, a green garden bot who “keeps our yard so green” and Zip, a yellow droid who “simply loves to clean.”



Each robot has its own color and its own function, and when their names are used, they’re in all caps and the color of the robots themselves (That is, Blink’s name is lettered in red, Zinc’s in purple, etc.)

The robots go about their business of cooking, fixing, yard-working and cleaning for several beautiful pages, and then they all join Blip outside for more work.

Then it starts to rain, which makes the anthropomorphic house kinda sad, and then suddenly four bolts of lighting strike the four robots, who immediately begin to malfunction. They continue to do their assigned jobs, but on different targets (Blip rakes the windows, Zip shines the grass, etc), which leads to chaos.



Then they come up with the perfect solution—they simply swap heads!



Note the lettering of their names once their heads are switched; it suddenly reflects their new color schemes. Now the heads force the bodies to do their assigned jobs, and on the right targets. It ends happily with the four of them gathered around a table, drinking tea and eating a chocolate tart. Can robots drink? Can they eat?

Apparently they can.

And the moral of this story? It doesn’t actually apply to humans; it’s merely practical advice to robots about staying out of the rain and part-sharing in general.



*Provided that is the moral, since everyone knows that the plain fry cake, perhaps with chocolate icing and sprinkles, is the very best doughnut. I may be misreading the message of the book, however. It may instead simply be a lesson in one of the most important aspects of starting a small business—location, location, location.